To register, click "create an account" at bottom. If already registered, just login below.

Thanks for registering!
Login/Register

That iceberg looming just ahead...is global warming

100 years ago, Titanic's Captain Smith steamed ahead full speed, despite iceberg warnings. By time the fatal 'berg was visible, it was too late to turn the big ship. Today, the looming hazard is global warming. Will we heed the warnings in time to change course?

 


 

 notes:  The Titanic had plenty of warning.   Seven ships had telegraphed iceberg sightings to the Titanic.  But Captain Smith only saw one or two; the other messages were scattered among various officers.   If Smith had seen all seven warnings, and plotted their locations, he might have recognized that a huge ice field lay just ahead.   Instead, he only receive one or two messages, adjusted his course slightly, and steamed  ahead full speed into the night.

The last message was sent urgently from the nearby Californian, which saw so many icebergs that it turned off its engine and stopped, surrounded by ice, to await daylight.  The Titanic radio operator cut off the Californian, replying "Shut up!  Shut up!   I'm busy..."    What was he busy with?   Relaying personal greetings from passengers, and never delivered the last urgent warning to Captain Smith.

Why didn't Smith at least slow down?   One reason may have been that the White Line's chairman, Bruce Ismay, who was on board for the maiden voyage, kept pressing Smith to go faster so they could break the record time set by a sister ship.   It was Ismay who, during construction, rejected a proposal to outfit the ship with enough lifeboats for everybody on board, since this was not required by regulations and would have been very costly.  

Does anything in this story sound familiar?

See also:   "But we can't afford to change our ways."

source:  Butler, Daniel Allen.  Unsinkable (2002).

image source: 

http://eng.namonitore.ru/wallpapers/big/aysberg_izpod_vodi_1024.html

Rating
★★★★
1 vote
379.jpg

Bite Details

Submitted by
Tom Smerling
Created
2012-04-19
Com (1)
byBrian Ettling

April 20, 2012

Thanks for a brief description of how the Titanic captain, the ship's owner, the officers, the radio operator all ignored the warning the warning of the iceberg. Yes, it does sound familiar...very similar to the warnings we are currently receiving about climate change. Yet, we keep ignoring them. I have been thinking about Titanic a lot and I even blogged about it myself a few days ago on http://begreenstartingnow.blogspot.com.

By the way, there is a problem with your text bleeding into your bite image and bite details. Still, it is a very good bite.
Owner's reply

Brian -- Thanks for the comment. The Titanic analogy just shouts at us, but it's hard to figure out how to capture it most compellingly and succinctly.

I'm having trouble reproducing the "text bleeding" problem. Can you please send a screen shot (then perhaps move this technical discussion to the forum)?

Please comment on this bite»